HKA assists utility in recovering legal expenses through rate base
Brief
Since 1982, an energy regulatory body has charged utilities throughout the United States a fee for every kilowatt-hour of electricity sold by nuclear power plants. In return for the fee, the energy regulatory body was required to begin removing the highly radioactive used nuclear fuel from these plants no later than January 31, 1998. The energy regulatory body had yet to perform this, causing a delay in performance for the client utility. The utility incurred significant costs to store substantially greater quantities of discharged spent fuel on-site at one of its nuclear power plants than it would have had the energy regulatory body performed as contractually required.
In 2000, following unsuccessful attempts at settlement, the utility filed a complaint with the U.S. Court of Federal Claims to recover the costs that would not have otherwise been incurred if the energy regulatory body had performed its contractual obligations. After an extended proceeding that culminated in a lengthy trial in 2007, the utility successfully settled its claim against the energy regulatory body for approximately US$45.5 million in 2011.
What we did
HKA experts were retained by outside counsel for the client utility to provide detailed analyses of various spent nuclear fuel cases and litigation fees incurred. We memorialized the results of the analyses in pre-filed rebuttal testimony with the state’s Public Service Commission (PSC), which regulates the state’s public utilities. Our rebuttal testimony detailed various aspects of the utility’s spent nuclear fuel suit and compared it to other spent nuclear fuel cases, noting various unique issues and aspects of the utility’s spent nuclear fuel case regarding damages and causation.
HKA’s rebuttal testimony also opined that a head-to-head comparison between any two spent nuclear fuel cases is difficult at best, especially given the significant differences between other spent nuclear fuel cases and the current case. After detailing specific issues and facts related to the utility’s spent nuclear fuel matter, HKA opined that the legal fees incurred in this case were reasonable and in line with, or less than, those incurred by other utilities in other cases. Our experts also testified live at a PSC hearing on the matter, with cross-examination by interveners and PSC staff.
Outcomes
The state’s PSC decided not to reduce the amount of legal fees recovered by the client utility. The PSC found that it was “difficult to determine the reasonableness of legal expenses in one case by comparing them to legal expenses from another case.” This finding validated or adopted the conclusions and opinions provided in the HKA pre-filed and live testimony. Through our experts’ knowledge of the nuclear industry, and specifically of spent nuclear fuel matters, we were able to assist the utility in fully recovering its legal expenses from the spent nuclear fuel suit.
The utility has and will continue to refund its customers the settlement amount from the energy regulatory body. After an intervener group compared the settlement the utility received from the energy regulatory body with the legal costs expended against the settlement amount and legal fees of another utility, it proposed a reduction in the legal fees the utility could recover from the rate base.
"Through our experts’ knowledge of the nuclear industry, and specifically of spent nuclear fuel matters, we were able to assist the utility in fully recovering its legal expenses from the spent nuclear fuel suit."
-
ClientUtility
-
ValueUS$45.5 million
RELATED PROJECTS
RELATED PROJECTS

Subsea Interconnector Cable Failure
Europe

Independent Quantum Expert Review of Maintenance Contract
Europe

Major Light Rail Transit
Americas

Two New Venues
Middle East

A Major Teaching & Research Hospital
Europe

Nuclear Power Plant
Americas

New School Campus, Ultimo Primary School
Oceania

UNSW Capital Projects Sustainability Framework
Oceania

Sydney Water, Partnering for Success (P4S)
Oceania

Melbourne Airport Rail
Oceania

Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) Project Australia
Oceania

Residential Development
Middle East

Natural Gas-Fired Power Plant
Asia

Industrial Manufacturing Facility
Europe

Subsea Power Cable Failure
Asia

Subsea Cable Installation & Trenching Operations
Asia

Independent Commercial, Cost & Risk Review of Road Development
Europe

Energy and Telecom Cable Manufacturer
Americas & Asia

Franchise Fraudulent Transfer Matter
Americas

Clean Fuels Project
Middle East

Nuclear Power Plant Decommissioning
Americas

Global chemicals manufacturer
Americas & Europe

Home security company sale agreement
Americas

Business Park, Surrey
Europe

Highway Rock Cuttings
Middle East

Coal-fired power plant
Asia

Coal-fired power plant
Americas

Water desalination plant
Americas

Offshore refinery contractor performance review
Asia

WestConnex Rozelle Interchange
Oceania

Public transport service improvement
Oceania

Independent Quantum Expert Opinion of Highway Maintenance Contract
Europe

Major Canadian Utility Commercial Damages Matter
Americas

South American Oil Refinery
Americas

Power Plant
Americas

University of North Carolina Hospitals
Americas

Longview Power Plant
Americas

Spent Nuclear Fuel Verdicts & Settlements
Americas

Missouri Power Plant
Americas

Share our Space Program
Oceania

Lower South Creek Treatment Program
Oceania

Allseas & Pioneering Spirit
Europe

Hume Community Housing
Oceania

Infrastructure Investment Assurance Framework
Oceania

Electricity Network Improvement
Oceania

Major Transport Projects Review
Oceania

High Speed 2 (HS2) Project
Europe

Urban Transformation & Transport Programme
Oceania

Strategic Procurement & Programme Management Improvement
Oceania

Business Reform & Procurement Strategy
Australia

Sydney Metro
Oceania

Temporary School at Ultimo Primary School
Oceania

Gerald Desmond Bridge
Americas

Office and Retail Landmark
Americas

Port of Long Beach
Americas

Airport Pavement Management Survey
Americas

Greenfield St George Airport, Utah
Americas

A Giant Oilfield
Asia

Hunter River Remediation
New South Wales, Australia

Great Western Highway Widening
Victoria, Australia

Rail Rehabilitation Scheme
Bucharest to Brasov line, Romania

Yanbu Power & Desalination Plant
Yanbu Industrial City, Saudi Arabia
Follow HKA on WeChat
关注我们的官方微信公众号
